About Pine Island Tap House
Pine Island Tap House is a brewery and taproom in Pine Island, New York. It opened in 2016 inside the old Pine Island firehouse. Its website says the on-site brewery qualifies as a New York State Farm Brewery.
The website says the house beers use at least 60% New York State hops and other locally sourced ingredients. Google also lists the place as a bar, beer garden and beer store. The website describes pub fare, and says the tap house has offered rotating food trucks.
There is indoor seating and an outdoor patio. The website mentions sunset views over the Black Dirt region. It also describes live music, from acoustic sets to full bands, and music bingo.
The tap house takes private events too. More people have reviewed Pine Island Tap House on Google than any other brewery, taproom or beer shop in Pine Island on this site.
From Pine Island Tap House's own website and its Google listing, read October 27, 2026.
Been here? Write the first Brewery.fyi review.
Map
Questions people ask
Does Pine Island Tap House brew its own beer?
Yes. Its website says it has an on-site brewing space that qualifies as a New York State Farm Brewery. It says the house beers use at least 60% New York State hops and other locally sourced ingredients.
Is there outdoor seating?
Yes. The website describes indoor seating and an outdoor patio. Google also lists it as a beer garden.
Is there live music?
The website describes live music, from acoustic sets to upbeat bands. It also mentions music bingo. Check its events page for what is coming up.
Can I rent the space for a private event?
Yes. The website invites you to rent the venue for a private event and has a contact page for questions.
Which breweries are close by?
Glenmere Brewing Company in Florida is 6.1 miles away. Shepherd's Eye Brewing Company in Florida and Orange County Brewing Company in New Hampton are each 6.4 miles away. Drowned Lands Brewery in Warwick is 8.4 miles away.
Answers come from Pine Island Tap House's website and its Google listing, read October 27, 2026.
Breweries near Pine Island Tap House
Before you visit Pine Island Tap House
Look for the old firehouse on County Road 1. Check pineislandtaphouse.com for the current tap list and the events page. The site is also the place to confirm hours before you drive out.
Plan to stay a while if the weather is good. The patio and the sunset views over the farm fields are a big part of the draw.
Glenmere Brewing Company is 6.1 miles away. Shepherd's Eye Brewing Company and Orange County Brewing Company are each 6.4 miles away, so a second stop is easy.